Maria Lourdes Sereno, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines. Photo by: Ramon FVelasquez.[/caption]
In the Philippine context, this is not the first time that judicial independence has been undermined.
In the years leading to the dark years of the Marcos conjugal dictatorship, former strongman Ferdinand Marcos consolidated the military and the police before he declared the imposition of martial law. He then clamped on the legislative and the Supreme Court, which, was by then packed with his appointees who lamely bowed to him and later legitimized his authoritarian rule.
Luis Teodoro, former dean of the University of the Philippines’ College of Mass Communication and a long-time progressive journalist, noted in his weekly column that justices during the first year of the Marcos dictatorship also refused to rule on the legality of the arrest and detention of known opposition leaders and scores of activists and journalists.
Once Again, Judicial Independence is Under Siege in Philippines
Janess Ann Ellao
April 23, 2018
Written by the Via News newsroom. From our archive, published before source-traceability. How we work

MANILA, Philippines (ViaNews) - Just recently, various groups of lawyers here in Manila have sought the intervention of the United Nations to look into the attacks on judicial independence as no less than the tough-talking Philippine president Rodrigo Duterte has publicly joined the fray in the present moves to unseat the chief justice. Critics have long argued that the removal of the Chief Justice is a part of a concerted effort that will lead to a dictatorial rule.
“I will punch you. I will help any investigator. I will really punch you. So I’m putting you on notice that I am now your enemy and you have to out of the Supreme Court,” said President Duterte, in an obvious response to Chief Justice Ma. Lourdes Sereno’s April 9 Valor Day speech, where she questioned the so-called powers-that-be behind the ouster moves against her.
While this is President Duterte’s first public pronouncement calling for the ouster of Chief Justice Sereno, the latter has been seemingly battling against nearly the entire might of the state, including her very own colleagues in the Supreme Court who testified in the impeachment charges filed before the House of Representatives last year. Now she is presently facing a controversial quo warranto petition filed by the Solicitor General early 2018.
But what does the ousting of the present Chief Justice really mean for the Philippines?
The unseating of the Chief Justice, according to critics like the progressive group Bayan, would allow President Duterte to “appoint a CJ (chief justice) who will tow the line of the administration,” given Sereno’s vote against the president’s pet issues such as the imposition of martial law in Mindanao and the heroes’ burial of the late strongman Marcos.
[caption id="attachment_4022" align="aligncenter" width="696"]
Maria Lourdes Sereno, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines. Photo by: Ramon FVelasquez.[/caption]
In the Philippine context, this is not the first time that judicial independence has been undermined.
In the years leading to the dark years of the Marcos conjugal dictatorship, former strongman Ferdinand Marcos consolidated the military and the police before he declared the imposition of martial law. He then clamped on the legislative and the Supreme Court, which, was by then packed with his appointees who lamely bowed to him and later legitimized his authoritarian rule.
Luis Teodoro, former dean of the University of the Philippines’ College of Mass Communication and a long-time progressive journalist, noted in his weekly column that justices during the first year of the Marcos dictatorship also refused to rule on the legality of the arrest and detention of known opposition leaders and scores of activists and journalists.
Maria Lourdes Sereno, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines. Photo by: Ramon FVelasquez.[/caption]
In the Philippine context, this is not the first time that judicial independence has been undermined.
In the years leading to the dark years of the Marcos conjugal dictatorship, former strongman Ferdinand Marcos consolidated the military and the police before he declared the imposition of martial law. He then clamped on the legislative and the Supreme Court, which, was by then packed with his appointees who lamely bowed to him and later legitimized his authoritarian rule.
Luis Teodoro, former dean of the University of the Philippines’ College of Mass Communication and a long-time progressive journalist, noted in his weekly column that justices during the first year of the Marcos dictatorship also refused to rule on the legality of the arrest and detention of known opposition leaders and scores of activists and journalists.
While it is true that Chief Justice Sereno has voted against President Duterte’s pet issues, both petitions questioning the imposition of martial law in Mindanao and the hero’s burial for the late strongman Marcos actually won to the detriment of the demands of many victims of human rights violations. This begs an important question. Why is the present administration so fixated on securing this seemingly much-coveted position when, in the end, she or he only carries a mere one vote? Apart from being the public persona, the chief justice, one of the 15-member collegial body, looks into the administrative matters and presides over sessions. She or he also chairs the Judicial and Bar Council and will serve as the presiding officer in an impeachment trial of the president. Or, quite simply, could it be possible that President Duterte cannot handle nor tolerate the slightest and smallest dissent?
Are you or your business in this article?
If something is wrong, out of context or missing, tell us. We correct errors with a dated note, and people named in an article can publish their response under it.
Correct, add context or respond →Not a source? Spotted an error? Report an error
How this story was made
Spotted an error? Use “Correct this article” (bottom right), or select any sentence, to report it or respond to that point.
- Published before we listed source documents with each article.
- Published 23 Apr 2018 · Last updated 7 Jan 2020
- No responses yet from the people or organisations in this story. Are you in this story? Respond on the record ›
- Part of the Via News record, fingerprinted daily so it cannot be quietly rewritten. What that means › · Report an error ›

Janess Ann Ellao
Janess Ann Ellao is a Philippine journalist and former managing editor at the online news outlet Bulatlat, covering health, women's issues and human rights. She has written for Via News on Philippine politics, human rights and the economy.
